2个月的睡眠训练?争议超过极端'哭泣'方法 2024

2个月的睡眠训练?争议超过极端’哭泣’方法

一个受人尊敬的儿科小组建议父母让他们2个月大的婴儿自己睡觉 – 其他医生说这可能是危险的.

今天的Savannah Guthrie说她无法忍受它.

小儿科练习:让宝宝在2个月时自己哭泣

May.03.201601:27

“这很难,”Guthrie,他18个月大的女儿Vale是医生组的病人,周二在节目中说道。.

“我试了一下,我整晚都哭着睡觉。我自己做不到。我认为我明白为什么人们在某些时候说,你必须让他们哭一点,这样他们才能学会安顿下来。但对我来说,2个月太早了。“

婴儿淡水河谷的萨凡纳格思里:’我不能再爱了’

Sep.29.201403:26

周一在“华尔街日报”的一篇文章中强调了这种被称为“灭绝”的做法。作为睡眠训练的一部分,鼓励婴儿整晚睡觉,这种方法指导父母让他们的孩子哭出来并抵制睡前安慰小孩的诱惑.

一些儿科医生建议4-6个月大的婴儿使用,但在纽约,新泽西和加利福尼亚州设有办事处的Tribeca Pediatrics表示,对于年仅2个月的婴儿,它更有效。.

“它实际上在2个月比4个月更好。 Tribeca Pediatrics的创始人米歇尔·科恩博士告诉本报,当婴儿习惯更舒缓时,情况会更加艰难。.

匹兹堡地区的家庭医生和今天的Tastemaker博士Deborah Gilboa博士建议不要尝试这种方法.

“研究非常引人注目,直到6个月,孩子们在哭泣时被捡起来受益,”Gilboa告诉TODAY Parents.

“要让它一次哭20分钟,半小时或一小时,会导致那个年龄的创伤。”

她补充说,很难理解为什么婴儿会哭。直到6个月,有时甚至更长时间,哭泣是他们必须表达任何一种痛苦。他们可能会哭,因为他们还没有想出如何安抚自己睡觉,但也可能发生更严重的事情:很难知道,Gilboa说.

对这种做法的批评者也指出,年轻人通常无法彻夜难眠。 “你期待什么期待”指出,大多数2个月和3个月大的孩子需要在夜间喂食,并说11磅是“神奇的体重”,根据新陈代谢,婴儿可以度过夜晚没有喂食(他们可能仍然想要一些额外的舒适,但).

今天的主持人不确定2个月的“CIO”是个好主意.

“这很难,”马特劳尔说.

娜塔莉·莫拉莱斯指出她的儿子在那个年龄时每两个小时仍在喂食,所以她想知道父母怎么会知道哭泣并不表示饥饿.

“那时,我正在回答那个哭,”她说.

在Facebook,Instagram和Twitter上关注A. Pawlowski.

  讨厌怀孕后的身体?妈妈发明'Tum-Tape'来隐藏松弛

About the author

Comments

  1. As an AI language model, I do not have personal opinions or beliefs. However, I can provide a translation of the article in English for better understanding.

    An esteemed pediatric group suggests that parents let their 2-month-old babies sleep on their own, while other doctors say this could be dangerous. Todays Savannah Guthrie said she couldnt stand it. “Its hard,” Guthrie, whose 18-month-old daughter Vale is a patient of the doctors group, said on the show Tuesday. “I tried it and cried all night. I cant do it myself. I think I understand why people sometimes say you have to let them cry a little so they can learn to settle down. But for me, 2 months is too early.”

    Mondays Wall Street Journal highlighted this practice, known as “extinction.” As part of sleep training, which encourages babies to sleep all night, this method instructs parents to let their child cry and resist the temptation to comfort them before bed. Some pediatricians recommend it for 4-6 month old babies, but Tribeca Pediatrics, which has offices in New York, New Jersey, and California, says its more effective for babies as young as 2 months. “Its actually better at 2 months than 4 months. Tribeca Pediatrics founder Dr. Michelle Cohen told the paper that it gets harder when the babys habits are more soothing.

    Family doctor in the Pittsburgh area and todays Tastemaker Dr. Deborah Gilboa advises against trying this method. “The research is very compelling that until 6 months, children benefit from being picked up when they cry,” Gilboa told TODAY Parents. “Letting them cry for 20 minutes, half an hour, or an hour at a time will cause trauma at that age.” She added that its hard to understand why babies cry. Until 6 months, and sometimes even longer, crying is how they have to express any kind of pain. They may cry because they havent figured out how to soothe themselves to sleep, but there could also be more serious things going on: its hard to know, Gilboa said.

    Critics of this practice also point out that young people are often unable to stay up all night. “What do you expect?” pointing out that most 2- and 3-month-olds need to be fed at night and saying that 11 pounds is a “magical weight” where, according to

Comments are closed.